At Bertram's Hotel - Not one of Agatha Christie's finest

In a nutshell

A plodding whodunit which takes its own sweet time to set things up but doesn't quite deliver the punch at the end with its reveal.

Plot

Miss Marple returns to a favorite childhood spot, Bertram's hotel, to experience the nostalgia of the bygone years. The hotel's guests include Miss Marple's gregarious friend Selena Hazy, absent minded Canon Pennyfather who's making his way to a conference in Lucerne via London, hypervigilant Colonel Luscombe accompanied by his precocious ward Elvira Blake and tabloid friendly socialite Lady Bess Sedgwick who always seems to have a knack of generating headlines. While Miss Marple does take great pleasure in the comforts of the place she also quickly comes to sense that there's something sinister going on behind all that external facade.

While a motley group of characters is permeating Bertram's hotel, the city is being terrorized by the daring thefts of a criminal gang which has evaded the police by skillfully impersonating prominent people. Hot on their trail is Chief Inspector Fred Davy who has painstakingly studied the gang's modus operandi and has unearthed a vital clue in his investigation. Almost everyone whom the gang impersonates ends up being a guest at Bertram's hotel.

When Canon Pennyfather disappears on his way to the airport and is miraculously identified at the site of a major railroad robbery, Chief Inspector Davy decides to finally make his way to Bertram's hotel and smoke out the perpetrators. Most of his inquiries are stonewalled until he meets Miss Marple who lets out two vital pieces of information:

She saw the Canon exiting his hotel room at midnight on the day he disappeared
A certain race car driver who's doing the rounds of the hotel seems to have caught the fancy of Ms. Elvira Blake

Chief Inspector Davy is intrigued by both pieces of information. A race car was reported to have been the main getaway vehicle at several of the lootings. But before a link is established between the vehicle and the thefts, Canon Pennyfather mysteriously returns with a bump on his head and Elvira Blake survives an attempt on her life. The bullets aimed at Elvira end up taking the life of Bertram's commissionaire, Michael Gorman.

It turns out that Ms. Elvira Blake is the sole heir to a wealthy estate and is going to come into a lot of money on her 21st birthday. It's also revealed that she's been scared that someone is after her life for quite some time.

Chief Inspector Davy deduces that the thefts and the murder are interconnected in onr way or the other and invites Miss Marple for a reconstruction of the night Cannon Pennyfather came back to the hotel after leaving for the airport.

The reconstruction alongwith Miss Marple's recollection of certain vital facts propels Chief Inspector Davy to apprehend the guilty parties.

What didn't work for me?

1. In a peculiar twist, although Bertram's Hotel is touted as a Miss Marple mystery, she's not a central character in the plot with Chief Inspector Davy taking the lead role in the investigation

2. All throughout the novel, Miss Marple just seems to be there at the right place at the right time picking up on all of the suspicious interactions. Instead of deductive reasoning its happenstance which unveils critical clues watering down the detection aspects that we come to expect from an Agatha Christie mystery

3. If you are a plundering ring with significant resources why would you repeatedly commit offences that would tie you to one single location - Bertram's Hotel?

Conclusion

Bertram's Hotel could have been the start of Agatha Christie's decline considering the fact that many of her works after this didn't generate the same level of excitement as those in her prime. I am all for slow burn thrillers (like Towards Zero) which take their time to move all the pieces into the right places but felt that Bertram Hotel's plot meanders quite a bit and never quite picks up the tempo to leave a mark. What did you feel when you read Bertram's Hotel? Let me know your thoughts.

Rated: Not quite worth your time

Until next time,

Your Agatha Christie fan

Comments

Zamarrud Theatre Hyderabad

More than two decades ago a 5 year old boy (yours truly) found himself in Abids which was certainly then the microcosm of Hyderabad. Abids in the 80s <Courtesy: OkaTeluguAbbayi > The occasion was a family outing to Zamarrud Cinema. And we are stepping out for not just any movie my friends, my parents decided that nothing less than the Raj Kapoor blockbuster Chori Chori was good enough for us. To be honest I wasn't exactly enthused about watching a black and white film of a bygone era even though the movie had all the credentials of a classic. But that was before I saw Zamarrud, the theatre where the movie was being played. Nested in the heart of Abids, Zamarrud was the perfect amalgamation of Hyderabad's old world charm and new fangled ways. Zamarrud was not just any theatre, it was one of the first air conditioned halls in Hyderabad, a premiere cinema hall which used to host the best of what the film industry had to offer and the place to go for Hyderabad...

Mahabharata by C.Rajagopalachari

There are books which you read and then there are books which make you read them and change your life. Chakravarthi Rajagopalachari's (Rajaji's) Mahabharata belongs to the latter category. Mahabharata introduced me to the joy of reading books as a kid and today I couldn't have picked a better topic for my 25th post. I cannot describe what a pleasure and honor it is to extol the virtues of this classic book during this holy festive season of Makar Sankranti . Mahabharata by C.Rajagopalachari The story of Mahabharata is as old as the mountains and has been retold several times. Mahabharata by Rajaji however stands out in my mind because here is a story which is spiritual yet not religious, is thought provoking yet not preachy, is compelling yet not tedious. The story left an indelible impression upon me for several reasons which are: Rajaji uses extremely simple language to convey some of the finer aspects of the saga. I was 10 years old when I read Mahabharata ...

A walk along the Ocean - Stanley Park Seawall

On a bright May afternoon I found myself on the Stanley Park Seawall in Vancouver facing the Pacific Ocean . This was the ocean hike that I was most looking forward to. Now before I go any further you might ask me. What is the Seawall? There you go, the picture below should answer your question very well 👇 Stanley Park Seawall (Courtesy: Tourism Vancouver) How did I get there? Simple via public transport ( TransLink ). In front of me was a 10 KM hike right next to the Pacific Ocean and I was grossly unprepared (didn't even have a bottle of water with me). But water or no water I wasn't about to back out from exploring this beautiful waterfront trail . My first pit stop allowed me to take in the sights of Vancouver downtown along with the docks . Vancouver Downtown Vancouver docks and the Pan Pacific Hotel Pan Pacific Hotel from the top (Courtesy: BC Ferries Vacations) The next sight to behold my attention was the 100 year old Brockton P...

The Punisher (2004)

There are very few movies which make for a fun repeat watch. The 2004 version of ' The Punisher ' belongs to this rarefied category. I watched the movie almost 10 years ago and then caught up with it again last month. The plot twists were familiar the second time around but the fun was still the same. That's what probably got me started off on this movie review. Tom Jane as 'The Punisher' The Plot: When the younger son of mafia boss Howard Saint ( John Travolta ) gets killed in an FBI operation headed by Frank Castle ( Tom Jane ), Saint swears revenge and wipes out Castle's entire family. Castle himself barely survives before emerging from his injuries as the crusading 'Punisher'. 'The Punisher' resolves to extract payback from Saint and proceeds to punish everyone on the wrong side of law with his brand of justice. Will 'The Punisher' succeed (Of course he does)? Watch this lesser talked about installment from the Marvel Cinematic Un...

KBR National Park

In the midst of the hustle and bustle of the fifth largest city in India - Hyderabad lies KBR (Kasu Brahmananda Reddy) National Park . It's difficult to imagine a natural habitat in the center of a concrete jungle but that's exactly what KBR park is - an oasis in middle of an urban desert . One of Hyderabad's prized tourist attractions which in my opinion doesn't get the attention it deserves. The Entrance <Courtesy: Andhra Aroma > I don't remember when I first noticed the park but it soon became a sight which I couldn't miss during the course of my everyday commute to work. I always wondered what lay beyond the entrance but never found the time to check it out for myself until last year. But let me back up a bit, there's a back story to my first visit to the park. In my ' Count Your Blessings ' post, I talked about how a walk around my office building started a positive change in my life. That incident made ' walking ' ...

Life Etc Etc

Search This Blog